Blog European Outlook: Less Downside Now, But Caution Still Warranted Focusing on high quality and liquidity when taking risk in portfolios will be key in 2023, as pressure on monetary policy remains intense.
In recent weeks evidence has mounted that the eurozone economy is proving resilient in the face of large shocks from higher energy prices and tighter financial conditions. After hitting a low of around 47 in October, the Eurozone Composite PMI climbed back to over 50 in January (see Figure 1), pointing to stagnation rather than outright contractions in activity. German industrial output, meanwhile, rose in November despite large falls in new orders during the month, reflecting the large order backlog built during the pandemic period. Impressively, the release of the preliminary German annual GDP print for 2022 implies that the economy expanded slightly in the final quarter of 2022, against broad-based expectations of a decline until recently. Figure 1: Eurozone PMI Source: PIMCO, Markit. As of 24 January 2023. While the precise drivers of this resilience are unclear, we would point to the following factors: production being supported by significant pent-up demand and order backlogs from the pandemic period; pent-up household savings cushioning the blow from higher inflation; resilient labor markets, likely reflecting corporate caution over staff dismissals, given recent global labor supply shortfalls; and finally, a sharp turn in wholesale gas prices softening the energy price shock on households and, especially, corporates. Lower recession risk but issues persist While our expectation has been that a recession would be mild in Europe, recent data implies we may avoid recession altogether. But while that may be good news in the near term, it doesn’t come without issues. In the December release, eurozone core inflation rose to a record 5.2% year-over-year (y/y), according to Eurostat. Some of this reflects price categories that are affected by global supply-side conditions and that will likely disinflate even if the economy is resilient. This would include core goods prices and service sector prices such as travel and accommodation, which are strongly affected by the post-pandemic re-opening. Still, for inflation to drop back to the European Central Bank (ECB) target of 2%, some cooling in the economy and in the labor market is likely required. To get a sense of how much cooling we need, assume that wage growth (measured by negotiated wages, per ECB data) moves from its current 3% y/y to 4%–4.5% ahead – a reasonable expectation given recent wage agreements. With trend productivity growth at around 1%, this would imply that unit labor cost (ULC) growth could settle at 3%–3.5%. To get to a level consistent with the ECB’s inflation target, ULCs and “sticky” core inflation must slow by 1 to 1.5 percentage points. Using data spanning back to the 1960s across 14 developed markets, we estimate that such a slowing in core prices could require an increase in the unemployment rate of 0.7 to 1.0 percentage points. However, so far, the unemployment rate has not moved at all, staying at a record low level of 6.5% in the eurozone in November. Granted, we still expect weakening activity ahead, as some of the support from order backlogs fades and as tighter monetary policy feeds into the economy. But if the recent underlying resilience persists, the prospect of the ECB having to hike more than is currently priced in the market (which is for a peak policy rate of around 3.5%) becomes very real. In investment portfolios, we believe upping quality and liquidity when taking risk and exercising caution around the most economically sensitive areas of the market makes sense. For details on our outlook for the global economy and investment implications for 2023, please read our latest Cyclical Outlook, “Strained Markets, Strong Bonds.” Nicola Mai leads PIMCO’s sovereign credit research in Europe.
Blog Fed Weighs Stubborn Inflation Against Banking System Stress Slower credit growth may curtail broader U.S. economic growth, taking pressure off the Federal Reserve.
Featured Solutions Modern Macro: A New Approach to an Old Strategy Deep uncertainty and market volatility provide fertile ground for macro hedge funds that can monetize not just the trends, but the volatility around the trends.
Blog 5 Key Takeaways from China’s 14th National People’s Congress China’s central government puts high-quality growth as top priority, along with continued support for business and opening-up.
Blog The ECB Hikes Rates Amid Financial Market Volatility In a dovish move, the central bank raises rates by half a point.
Blog Bank Failures and the Fed The failure of Silicon Valley Bank raises questions for Fed policy and economic growth.
Blog Regional Bank Stress Puts Spotlight on Cash Management Shocks to the U.S. banking system underscore how even cash holdings can involve risk and also suggest that the timeline for a recession may have drawn nearer.
Blog The ECB Hikes Rates Amid Financial Market Volatility In a dovish move, the central bank raises rates by half a point.
Blog The ECB Is Not Done Yet The European Central Bank raised its policy rate, and more hikes are coming.
Blog ECB Hikes, and Indicates Higher Rates Coming The European Central Bank is likely to continue hiking rates next year, but the end point remains uncertain.